This Case Status Key and Glossary explains how to read each case status in Just Security’s Litigation Tracker and how to interpret a given ruling’s effect on the challenged executive action. We hope these resources make it easier to follow individual cases, spot emerging trends, and understand how courts are responding.
Case Status Key
Decision(s) Pending
The case is active and no substantive ruling has been issued yet.
| Status | What It Means |
| Decision Pending | The case has been filed and is active, but no ruling has been issued yet, the preliminary block has elapsed, or a prior ruling was vacated and no other ruling is currently in effect (see Glossary). |
Decision(s) in Favor of Plaintiff(s)
A court has issued a ruling — at any stage of litigation, including on preliminary motions — that pauses or blocks the challenged government action for the plaintiff(s) who brought the case. This category reflects the current posture of the case, not necessarily a final outcome. A ruling in favor of plaintiff(s) on a preliminary motion does not mean plaintiffs have prevailed on the merits; litigation is typically ongoing.
| Status | What It Means |
| Government Action Temporarily Blocked | A district court has issued a temporary restraining order (TRO), preliminary injunction (PI), or a stay under 5 U.S.C. § 705 (Section 705 Stay), pausing the government action while the litigation continues. The temporary block remains in effect until it expires or is stayed or vacated by a further court order. |
| Government Action Blocked | A district court has ruled that at least one of the challenged government actions is unlawful — through a permanent injunction on the merits or other available remedy — and has constrained or blocked the government’s ability to carry it out. Rulings on any other challenged actions or claims may still be pending. |
| Government Action Temporarily Blocked; Appeal Pending | A district court has granted a TRO, PI, or Section 705 Stay, pausing the government action; the government has appealed, but the appellate court has not yet issued a decision. The block remains in effect during this period until the appellate court orders otherwise. |
| Government Action Blocked; Appeal Pending | A district court has blocked the government action on the merits; the government has appealed, but the appellate court has not yet issued a decision. The block remains in effect during this period until the appellate court orders otherwise. |
| Government Action Temporarily Blocked; Appellate Court Affirmed Block | A district court had temporarily paused the government action via a TRO, PI, or Section 705 Stay; the government appealed, and the appellate court affirmed that block. The government action remains paused while the litigation continues. |
| Government Action Blocked; Appellate Court Affirmed Block | A district court had blocked the government action on the merits; the government appealed, and the appellate court affirmed that block. The government action remains blocked. |
| Case Closed in Favor of Plaintiff(s) | The case has concluded, and the plaintiff(s) largely obtained the result they sought. This includes cases with a final judgment for the plaintiff(s) and no further avenues for appeal, and cases in which the government rescinded or abandoned the challenged action, and the case was dismissed as moot (see Glossary) or voluntarily dismissed, whether by the plaintiff(s) alone or by joint stipulation of both parties. Where mootness or a voluntary dismissal results from other circumstances, see Case Closed. Where a case ended through a settlement in which the plaintiff(s) also made concessions, see Case Closed; Split Outcome. |
Decision(s) in Favor of Government
A court has issued a ruling — at any stage of litigation, including on preliminary motions — that allows the government action to proceed. This category reflects the current posture of the case, not necessarily a final outcome. A ruling in favor of the government on a preliminary motion does not mean the government has prevailed on the merits; litigation is typically ongoing.
| Status | What It Means |
| Temporary Block of Government Action Denied | A district court has denied a request for a TRO, PI, or Section 705 Stay, or the TRO, PI, or Section 705 Stay request was denied or dissolved as moot (including where underlying claims were dismissed on a partial ruling); the government action may continue while the litigation proceeds. |
| Block of Government Action Denied | A district court has denied a request to block the government action on the merits; the government action may proceed. |
| Temporary Block of Government Action Denied; Appeal Pending | A district court has denied a request for a TRO, PI, or Section 705 Stay; the plaintiff(s) have appealed, but the appellate court has not yet issued a decision. The government action may continue during this period until the appellate court orders otherwise. |
| Block of Government Action Denied; Appeal Pending | A district court has denied a request to block the government action on the merits; the plaintiff(s) have appealed, but the appellate court has not yet issued a decision. The government action may proceed during this period until the appellate court orders otherwise. |
| Government Action Temporarily Unblocked by Appellate Court | A district court had temporarily paused the government action via a TRO, PI, or Section 705 Stay (see Government Action Temporarily Blocked) and an appellate court has paused the effect of the district court order(s), allowing the government to continue the action while appellate review proceeds. This case status may reflect the appellate court vacating the district court’s decision, or the appellate court issuing an administrative stay (see Glossary) of a district court ruling in favor of plaintiff(s) while it considers a motion for a stay pending appeal (see Glossary). The case update will indicate which applies and whether a further ruling is forthcoming. The government action may proceed while the litigation continues. |
| Government Action Unblocked by Appellate Court | A district court had blocked the government action on the merits; the government appealed, and the appellate court reversed or vacated the district court’s decision. The government action may proceed. |
| Case Closed/Dismissed in Favor of Government | The case has concluded, and the challenged government action remains in place. This may mean the court issued a final judgment for the government; the case was dismissed on threshold grounds — such as lack of standing, lack of subject-matter jurisdiction, or sovereign immunity — in a way that leaves the government action in place; or the case was dismissed as moot because the challenged government action was implemented or became irreversible and the court concluded it could no longer provide meaningful relief. Plaintiffs’ voluntary dismissal is classified as a government victory only where the record shows the plaintiff dismissed after an adverse ruling, obtained no relief, and the challenged government action remains in place. Where a case is closed for other reasons not clearly favoring either party, see Case Closed. |
Decision(s) in Favor of Both Parties
A court has issued a ruling that partially blocks the challenged government action and partially allows it to proceed. This category reflects the current posture of the case, not necessarily a final outcome.
| Status | What It Means |
| Government Action Temporarily Blocked in Part; Temporary Block Denied in Part | A court has granted a TRO, PI, or Section 705 Stay as to some claims or parties, but denied it as to others. |
| Government Action Temporarily Blocked in Part; Temporary Block Denied in Part; Appeal Pending | A court has granted a TRO, PI, or Section 705 Stay as to some claims or parties, but denied it as to others — or has granted separate TROs, PIs, or Section 705 Stays on distinct claims where one has since been stayed by an appellate court pending appeal while the other remains in force. In either case, one or more parties has appealed, and the appellate court has not yet issued a decision on at least one of those appeals. Each ruling remains in effect (blocked or unblocked, as applicable) until the relevant appellate court orders otherwise. |
| Government Action Blocked in Part; Block Denied in Part | A court has ruled on the merits, blocking the government action in some respects but not others. |
| Government Action Blocked in Part; Block Denied in Part; Appeal Pending | A court has granted a permanent injunction as to some claims or parties, but denied it as to others; one of the parties has appealed, but the appellate court has not yet issued a decision. The court ruling remains in effect during this period until the appellate court orders otherwise. |
| Case Closed; Split Outcome | The case has concluded without a full victory for either party. This case status may reflect a settlement in which both parties made substantive concessions, or a final court ruling that resolved the case partially in favor of each party. |
Case Closed
The case has concluded without a ruling on the merits or without an explicit win or loss for either party.
| Status | What It Means |
| Case Closed | The case has concluded without a clear win or loss for either party. For example, the case has been dismissed by agreement of the parties, the court has found the issues moot (see Glossary) in a manner that is not clearly a win or a loss for either party, or the plaintiffs have voluntarily dismissed the case and the record does not clearly show which party prevailed. When the record is silent or ambiguous about the reason for plaintiffs’ voluntary dismissal, the case is classified as Case Closed, because plaintiffs may dismiss a case for many reasons, including settlement, a change in strategy, or an intent to refile. Plaintiffs’ voluntary dismissal is classified as a government victory only where the record shows the plaintiff dismissed after an adverse ruling, obtained no relief, and the challenged government action remains in place (see Case Closed/Dismissed in Favor of Government). |
Glossary
Affirmed: When a higher court agrees with a lower court’s decision and leaves it in place, meaning the lower court’s ruling remains in legal effect.
Administrative Procedure Act (APA): A federal act that governs the procedures of administrative law. The APA establishes how administrative agencies make rules (“rulemaking,” which is defined as “the agency process for formulating, amending, or repealing a rule”) and how agencies adjudicate administrative litigation, meaning how they resolve specific agency matters by issuing orders. Under 5 U.S. Code § 706, federal courts may “hold unlawful and set aside” agency action that is arbitrary and capricious, contrary to law, or procedurally defective. Courts may also issue stays under Section 705 (see below).
Administrative Stay: A brief temporary pause, often lasting only a few days, that a court may grant alongside its own ruling or in response to an emergency motion. When issued by a district court, an administrative stay gives the losing party a short window to seek emergency relief from a higher court before the ruling takes full effect. When issued by an appellate court, an administrative stay gives the court time to consider an emergency motion — such as a motion for a stay pending appeal — before ruling on it. In either case, an administrative stay does not reflect the merits of the ruling itself.
Emergency Application: A request to the Supreme Court to act quickly — such as by staying a lower court’s ruling — without necessarily committing to a full review of the lower court’s ruling. These are often decided without full briefing or argument and with little or no published reasoning.
Moot/Mootness: A case becomes moot when the court determines that there is no longer a live controversy that it can resolve. This can occur for several reasons — for example, because a party has rescinded or abandoned the challenged action, or because circumstances have otherwise changed such that the court can no longer provide meaningful relief. A finding of mootness usually results in dismissal of the case. Courts recognize limited exceptions to this doctrine, however, including when a party has voluntarily stopped the conduct but could resume it (“voluntary cessation”), or when the challenged action is time-bound in a way that prevents review as to the specific parties but could reoccur for others (“capable of repetition, yet evading review”).
Preliminary Injunction (PI): A court order that temporarily stops a government action while the lawsuit continues. In determining whether to grant a PI, the court will apply a four-factor test: likelihood of success on the merits, likelihood of irreparable harm, balance of equities, and public interest. The requesting party bears the burden of establishing the test is satisfied. Unlike a TRO, a PI does not typically have a fixed expiration date. The PI stays in place until the court changes it (modifies or dissolves it), a higher court overturns it, or the case is resolved on the merits — meaning the court has actually decided the substance of the dispute. In practice, a PI can remain in place for months or years.
Permanent Injunction: A final court order that permanently blocks a government action after the court has fully ruled on the merits of the case. (Like all parts of a final judgment, if made by a lower court it may still be subject to appeal.)
Section 705 Stay: Under 5 U.S. Code § 705, courts may “postpone the effective date of an agency action.” When a federal court issues a section 705 stay, the challenged federal agency action may be temporarily paused while the litigation is ongoing.
Stay Pending Appeal: When a district court has ruled and a party appeals (for example, the plaintiff(s) appealing a denial, the government appealing a block), either party may ask the appellate court to “stay” (pause) the district court’s order while the appeal proceeds. If the appellate court grants a stay, the district court’s ruling is paused during the appeal. If the appellate court denies a stay, the district court’s ruling remains in effect. Cases may escalate quickly — including to the Supreme Court — if a party seeks emergency relief.
Temporary Restraining Order (TRO): A short-term emergency court order that temporarily stops a government action, authorized under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 65(b). A TRO usually lasts no more than 14 days, although it may be extended “for good cause” or by mutual consent. It is often issued quickly after a lawsuit is filed to keep things from changing while the court considers whether to grant longer-term relief.
Vacated: When a court sets aside an earlier decision so that, once the vacatur takes effect, the earlier decision no longer has legal effect. When an appellate court vacates a lower court’s decision, the vacatur ordinarily takes effect when the mandate issues; until then, the lower court’s decision may remain operative unless the appellate court orders otherwise.
Writ of Certiorari: A formal order in which the Supreme Court agrees to review a lower court’s decision. The Supreme Court has discretion over which cases it accepts and only grants certiorari in a small fraction of cases petitioned each year.







