Skip to content
Justsecurity.org
A Forum on Law, Rights, and U.S. National Security
  • About Us
    • Masthead
    • Advisory Board
    • Guest Authors
    • Contact Us
    • More About Us
  • Key Topics
    • Congressional Oversight
    • Counterterrorism
    • Coronavirus
    • Cyber
    • Diplomacy
    • Immigration
    • Intelligence activities
    • International Criminal Law
    • International Human Rights
    • Law of Armed Conflict
    • Local Voices
    • Racial Justice
    • United Nations
    • Use of Force
  • Russia-Ukraine War
  • Featured Articles
  • Write for Us
  • A.M. and P.M. Emails
Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Facebook Donate Open the search tool Open the main navigation
Search for:
Search authors only
A Forum on Law, Rights, and U.S. National Security
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Masthead
    • Advisory Board
    • Guest Authors
    • Contact Us
  • Write for Just Security
  • Donate
  • Signups for A.M. and P.M. emails

DOJ’s appeal to district court judge from Magistrate Orenstein’s rejection of Apple All Writs Act order

by Marty Lederman

March 7, 2016

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to print (Opens in new window)

Filed under:

All Writs Act, Apple, EDNY, Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), Jamie Orenstein, Margo Brodie

by Marty Lederman

March 7, 2016

is here; I have not yet read it. It will be considered by Judge Margo Brodie.

Filed under:

All Writs Act, Apple, EDNY, Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), Jamie Orenstein, Margo Brodie

Signups for A.M. & P.M. Emails
Trump supporters storm the U.S. Capitol on January 6, 2021. They cover the stairs and the bleachers set up for the inauguration. They carry American flags, Trump flags, anti-Semitic flags, and other white supremacist flags.

January 6 Clearinghouse

All-source, public repository of congressional hearing transcripts, government agency documents, digital forensics, social media analysis, public opinion surveys, empirical research, more.

Read More about January 6 Clearinghouse

Featured Articles

  • Plyler’s Promise

    by Nicholas Espíritu

    May 20th, 2022

  • Still at War: The United States in Iraq

    by Crispin Smith

    May 18th, 2022

  • Biden’s New Counterterrorism Policy in Somalia: Cautions and Unknowns

    by Luke Hartig

    May 17th, 2022

  • An Offer NATO Cannot (and Should Not) Refuse: Finland’s Membership

    by Laleh Ispahani

    May 12th, 2022

  • Climate Security, Energy Security, and the Russia-Ukraine War

    by Mark Nevitt

    May 11th, 2022

  • Model Indictment for the Crime of Aggression Committed against Ukraine

    by James A. Goldston

    May 9th, 2022

  • War’s Aftermath in Ukraine: Preparing Now for the Day After

    by Ray Salvatore Jennings

    May 5th, 2022

  • January 6 Clearinghouse

    by Ryan Goodman and Justin Hendrix

    May 4th, 2022

  • U.S. Policy on Cluster Munitions and Russia’s War in Ukraine

    by Stephen Pomper

    May 4th, 2022

  • The Prohibition on Indiscriminate Attacks: The US Position vs. the DoD Law of War Manual

    by Brian Finucane

    May 3rd, 2022

  • The Beginning of the End for Criminal Defamation in the Americas? The El Universo Case

    by Justice Manuel José Cepeda Espinosa and Dario Milo

    May 3rd, 2022

  • Congressional Action on Civilian Harm Resulting from U.S. Military Operations: Part I

    by Annie Shiel and Sarah Yager

    Apr 28th, 2022

  • Congressional Action on Civilian Harm Resulting from U.S. Military Operations: Part II

    by Laura Dickinson, Brianna Rosen and Rachel VanLandingham, Lt Col, USAF (Ret.)

    Apr 28th, 2022

  • What Kind of Guilty Mind is Needed for the Criminal Contempt of Congress Statute?

    by Andy Wright

    Apr 26th, 2022

  • Russian Landmines in Ukraine: The Most Relevant Treaty

    by Michael Matheson

    Apr 25th, 2022

  • Time for the International Community to Get Serious About Protecting Human Rights in Afghanistan

    by Nasir A. Andisha and Hamid A. Formuli

    Apr 22nd, 2022

  • Legal Frameworks for Assessing the Use of Starvation in Ukraine

    by Tom Dannenbaum

    Apr 22nd, 2022

  • Focus on Accountability Risks Overshadowing Ukraine’s Reconstruction Needs

    by Rebecca Hamilton

    Apr 21st, 2022

  • How To Fix the Broken Position of U.S. Special Envoy for the Horn of Africa

    by Cameron Hudson

    Apr 20th, 2022

  • How the War in Ukraine Illustrates the Weakness of US Policy Toward Africa

    by Aude Darnal

    Apr 18th, 2022

  • Звіт ОБСЄ про воєнні злочини в Україні: ключові висновки

    by Adil Ahmad Haque

    Apr 15th, 2022

  • Putin’s Next Play in Ukraine – And How the US and Allies Can Prepare

    by Ambassador Daniel Fried

    Apr 15th, 2022

  • The OSCE Report on War Crimes in Ukraine: Key Takeaways

    by Adil Ahmad Haque

    Apr 15th, 2022

  • Still at War: The Forever War Legal Paradigm in Afghanistan

    by Laura Dickinson

    Apr 14th, 2022

  • How International Justice Can Succeed in Ukraine and Beyond

    by Christopher "Kip" Hale and Leila Nadya Sadat

    Apr 14th, 2022

  • Top Cover: Congressional Republicans Pave Way for US Policy Shift on Int’l Criminal Court

    by Ryan Goodman

    Apr 13th, 2022

  • A Warm Welcome to Just Security’s New Editorial Board Members!

    by Tess Bridgeman and Ryan Goodman

    Apr 12th, 2022

  • Why the War in Ukraine Poses a Greater Nuclear Risk than the Cuban Missile Crisis

    by Lawrence Korb and Stephen Cimbala

    Apr 12th, 2022

  • The Best Path for Accountability for the Crime of Aggression Under Ukrainian and International Law

    by Alexander Komarov and Oona Hathaway

    Apr 11th, 2022

  • Найкращий шлях до відповідальності за злочин агресії за українським та міжнародним правом

    by Alexander Komarov and Oona Hathaway

    Apr 11th, 2022

  • In Ukraine, There Are No Quick Fixes

    by John Erath

    Apr 8th, 2022

  • Still at War: The United States in the Sahel

    by Brian Finucane

    Apr 7th, 2022

  • Is Genocide Occurring in Ukraine? An Expert Explainer on Indicators and Assessments

    by Jonathan Leader Maynard

    Apr 6th, 2022

  • Pressing US Officials on Russia and Int’l Criminal Court: The Interview We Should be Hearing

    by Rebecca Hamilton

    Apr 6th, 2022

  • Ukraine’s Constitutional Constraints: How to Achieve Accountability for the Crime of Aggression

    by Alexander Komarov and Oona Hathaway

    Apr 5th, 2022

  • The Need to Reexamine the Crime of Aggression’s Jurisdictional Regime

    by Jennifer Trahan

    Apr 4th, 2022

  • Still at War: The United States in Somalia

    by Oona Hathaway and Luke Hartig

    Mar 31st, 2022

  • Articulating Arms Control Law in the EU’s Lethal Military Assistance to Ukraine

    by Tomas Hamilton

    Mar 30th, 2022

  • Ukraine May Mark a Turning Point in Documenting War Crimes

    by Justin Hendrix

    Mar 28th, 2022

  • Bargaining About War in the Shadow of International Law

    by Eyal Benvenisti and Amichai Cohen

    Mar 28th, 2022

  • Still at War: The United States in Yemen

    by Luke Hartig and Oona Hathaway

    Mar 24th, 2022

  • Introduction to Symposium: Still at War – Where and Why the United States is Fighting the “War on Terror”

    by Tess Bridgeman and Brianna Rosen

    Mar 24th, 2022

  • How States Can Prosecute Russia’s Aggression With or Without “Universal Jurisdiction”

    by Diane Orentlicher

    Mar 24th, 2022

  • How DOJ Could Prosecute Russians for War Crimes, and How Congress Can Expand Its Remit

    by Edgar Chen

    Mar 23rd, 2022

  • Why Pushing Russia Out of Multilateral Institutions is Not a Solution to the War

    by Fionnuala Ní Aoláin

    Mar 22nd, 2022

  • Why Congress Should Stay Out of U.S. Sanctions Policy on Russia

    by Edoardo Saravalle

    Mar 21st, 2022

  • The Way: The Chief Prosecutor, the Int’l Criminal Court, and Ukraine

    by David Schwendiman

    Mar 20th, 2022

  • Insight from Ukraine: Revitalizing Belief in International Law

    by Maksym Vishchyk

    Mar 18th, 2022

  • Why China Giving Military Assistance to Russia Would Violate International Law

    by Oona Hathaway and Ryan Goodman

    Mar 17th, 2022

  • Питання та відповіді: Наказ Міжнародного Суду ООН про тимчасові заходи у справі України проти Російської Федерації

    by Chimène Keitner, Zoe Tatarsky and Just Security

    Mar 16th, 2022

  • Q&A: The ICJ’s Order on Provisional Measures in Ukraine v. Russian Federation

    by Chimène Keitner, Zoe Tatarsky and Just Security

    Mar 16th, 2022

  • The Intersection of Accountability and Diplomacy in Addressing Russia’s War in Ukraine

    by David Bosco

    Mar 15th, 2022

  • Model Indictment for Crime of Aggression Against Ukraine: Prosecutor v. President Vladimir Putin

    by Ryan Goodman and Rebecca Hamilton

    Mar 14th, 2022

  • The Operational and Legal Risks of a No-Fly Zone Over Ukrainian Skies

    by Mark Nevitt

    Mar 10th, 2022

  • Механізми кримінального переслідування агресії Росії проти України

    by Tom Dannenbaum

    Mar 10th, 2022

  • Mechanisms for Criminal Prosecution of Russia’s Aggression Against Ukraine

    by Tom Dannenbaum

    Mar 10th, 2022

  • Commit Fully To Sanctions Now To Help Ukraine

    by Ambassador P. Michael McKinley (ret.)

    Mar 10th, 2022

  • U.S. Under Secretary of State Nuland on Accelerating Aid to Ukraine and Sanctions Against Russia

    by Viola Gienger

    Mar 9th, 2022

  • Питання та відповіді (Частина ІІ): Україна у Міжнародному суді справедливості, Відсутність Росії та що буде далі

    by Chimène Keitner, Zoe Tatarsky and Just Security

    Mar 9th, 2022

  • Q&A (Part II): Ukraine at the International Court of Justice, Russia’s Absence & What Comes Next

    by Chimène Keitner, Zoe Tatarsky and Just Security

    Mar 9th, 2022

  • Справедливість для України та аномальна політика уряду США щодо МКС

    by Adam Keith

    Mar 8th, 2022

  • Justice for Ukraine and the U.S. Government’s Anomalous Int’l Criminal Court Policy

    by Adam Keith

    Mar 8th, 2022

  • Генеральна Асамблея ООН повинна рекомендувати створення трибуналу для України щодо злочину агресії: Нюрнберг – це не модель

    by Jennifer Trahan

    Mar 7th, 2022

  • U.N. General Assembly Should Recommend Creation Of Crime Of Aggression Tribunal For Ukraine: Nuremberg Is Not The Model

    by Jennifer Trahan

    Mar 7th, 2022

  • Питання та відповіді: Наступні кроки щодо української заяви до МСС

    by Chimène Keitner, Zoe Tatarsky and Just Security

    Mar 5th, 2022

  • Q&A: Next Steps in Ukraine’s Application to the International Court of Justice

    by Chimène Keitner, Zoe Tatarsky and Just Security

    Mar 5th, 2022

  • Ukraine and War Powers: A Legal Explainer

    by Brian Finucane

    Mar 3rd, 2022

  • Вторгнення Росії в Україну є загрозою для правозахисників та політичних вигнанців

    by Isabel Linzer and Yana Gorokhovskaia

    Mar 3rd, 2022

  • Russia’s Invasion of Ukraine Imperils Human Rights Defenders and Political Exiles

    by Isabel Linzer and Yana Gorokhovskaia

    Mar 3rd, 2022

  • Змодельований щоденний звіт президента про Путіна та Україну

    by Brianna Rosen

    Mar 2nd, 2022

  • A Simulated President’s Daily Brief on Putin and Ukraine

    by Brianna Rosen

    Mar 2nd, 2022

  • The Good Governance Papers: A “Report Card” Wrap-Up of 2022 Updates

    by Emily Berman, Tess Bridgeman, Megan Corrarino, Ryan Goodman and Dakota S. Rudesill

    Mar 1st, 2022

  • The Russia-Ukraine Conflict, the Black Sea, and the Montreux Convention

    by Mark Nevitt

    Feb 28th, 2022

  • Ahead of the State of the Union: Analysis from Diplomats, Top Experts

    by Brianna Rosen and Tess Graham

    Feb 28th, 2022

  • Questions for Congress to Ask the Biden Administration at the AUMF Hearing

    by Brian Finucane

    Feb 28th, 2022

  • Holding Putin and Russia Accountable: A List of Legal and Policy Options

    by Viola Gienger, Tess Graham, Brianna Rosen and Elizabeth Whatcott

    Feb 25th, 2022

  • Putin Can’t Destroy the International Order by Himself

    by Oona Hathaway and Scott Shapiro

    Feb 24th, 2022

  • Expert Backgrounder: NATO Response Options to Potential Russia Cyber Attacks

    by Michael Schmitt

    Feb 24th, 2022

  • Russia’s Invasion of Ukraine Is Essentially Not About NATO

    by Maria Popova and Oxana Shevel

    Feb 24th, 2022

  • United States v. Donald Trump

    by Barbara McQuade

    Feb 22nd, 2022

  • Russia’s “Occupation by Proxy” of Eastern Ukraine – Implications Under the Geneva Conventions

    by Natia Kalandarishvili-Mueller

    Feb 22nd, 2022

  • 80 Years Later, Preventing Another Executive Order 9066 Requires Recognizing Its Lessons

    by David Inoue

    Feb 18th, 2022

  • Books Bans and Censored Curricula Won’t Change History – or the Racism We Still Live With

    by Shirley Ann Higuchi

    Feb 18th, 2022

  • Combating Anti-Asian Violence through UN Human Rights Mechanisms

    by Alyssa Yamamoto

    Feb 18th, 2022

  • 80 Years After Executive Order 9066, the Supreme Court Still Shuts Its Eyes to Reality

    by Lorraine K. Bannai

    Feb 18th, 2022

  • Introduction to Just Security’s Series on Executive Order 9066, 80 Years After Signing

    by Megan Corrarino

    Feb 18th, 2022

  • What I Told Congress about U.S. Lethal Strikes

    by Hina Shamsi

    Feb 17th, 2022

  • Deploring the Violence, Abandoning the Victim

    by Karen Musalo, Anne Dutton and Mark Hetfield

    Feb 17th, 2022

  • A Transitional Period Constitutional Question in Sudan

    by Nasredeen Abdulbari

    Feb 16th, 2022

  • “Freedom Convoy” Occupation Highlights Canada’s Security Challenges

    by Kent Roach

    Feb 14th, 2022

  • Does the Law Matter?: Coup Edition

    by Elizabeth Goitein

    Feb 11th, 2022

  • Ignore the War Hawks – on Iran, There is Still Time for a Deal

    by Emma Belcher

    Feb 10th, 2022

  • Clear Error in the Defense Department’s Law of War Manual: On Presumptions of Civilian Status

    by Ryan Goodman

    Feb 9th, 2022

  • State and Local Solutions Are Integral to Protect Election Officials and Democracy

    by Trey Grayson, Matthew Masterson, Orion Danjuma and Ben Berwick

    Feb 9th, 2022

  • A Big Step Forward or Running in Place?: The Pentagon’s New Policy on Civilian Casualties

    by Luke Hartig

    Feb 8th, 2022

  • Foreign Agents Registration Act Reform: On the 2022 Agenda?

    by Andy Wright, David Rybicki and Rachel Wofford

    Feb 7th, 2022

  • Disinformation, Radicalization, and Algorithmic Amplification: What Steps Can Congress Take?

    by Ambassador (ret.) Karen Kornbluh

    Feb 7th, 2022

  • Election Subversion and Electoral Count Act Reform

    by Richard Pildes

    Feb 2nd, 2022

  • Biden Team Gets It Right on Inadmissibility of Torture Evidence in Al-Nashiri Case

    by Tess Bridgeman

    Feb 1st, 2022

  • FARA’s Next Big Year

    by Brandon L. Van Grack and Haydn Forrest

    Jan 31st, 2022

Key Topics

Scroll within to view all topics.
  • Afghanistan
  • Congressional Oversight
  • Coronavirus
  • Counterterrorism
  • Cybersecurity
  • Diplomacy
  • Disinformation
  • Immigration
  • Intelligence activities
  • International Criminal Law
  • Law of Armed Conflict
  • Local Voices
  • Racial Justice
  • Social Media Platforms
  • United Nations
  • Use of Force

Resources

Litigation Trackers

  • Litigation Tracker: Major Decisions Facing the Biden Administration

    by Karl Mihm, Justin Cole, Iva Petkova, Margaret Shields, Mari Dugas, Nicholas Tonckens and Tess Bridgeman

    Nov 19th, 2021

  • Litigation Tracker: Pending Criminal and Civil Cases Against Donald Trump

    by Karl Mihm, Jacob Apkon and Sruthi Venkatachalam

    May 12th, 2022

Series

  • Introduction to Symposium: Still at War – Where and Why the United States is Fighting the “War on Terror”

    by Tess Bridgeman and Brianna Rosen

    Mar 24th, 2022

  • Introduction to Just Security’s Series on Executive Order 9066, 80 Years After Signing

    by Megan Corrarino

    Feb 18th, 2022

  • The Good Governance Papers: A January 2022 “Report Card” Update

    by Emily Berman, Tess Bridgeman, Megan Corrarino, Ryan Goodman and Dakota S. Rudesill

    Jan 20th, 2022

  • Introduction to Symposium: How Perpetual War Has Changed Us — Reflections on the Anniversary of 9/11

    by Tess Bridgeman, Rachel Goldbrenner and Ryan Goodman

    Sep 7th, 2021

  • Racing National Security: Introduction to the Just Security Symposium

    by Matiangai Sirleaf

    Jul 13th, 2020

  • New Just Security Series: Beyond the Myanmar Coup

    by Just Security

    Jul 19th, 2021

  • Introduction to Just Security’s Series on Tulsa Race Massacre of 1921

    by Christine Berger

    May 29th, 2021

  • The Good Governance Papers: An Introduction

    by Emily Berman, Tess Bridgeman, Ryan Goodman and Dakota S. Rudesill

    Oct 14th, 2020

Timelines

  • Timeline: Rep. Jim Jordan, a Systematic Disinformation Campaign, and January 6

    by Justin Hendrix, Nicholas Tonckens and Sruthi Venkatachalam

    Aug 29th, 2021

  • Mark Meadows Timeline: The Chief of Staff and Schemes to Overturn 2020 Election

    by Ryan Goodman and Juilee Shivalkar

    Aug 8th, 2021

  • The Official and Unofficial Timeline of Defense Department Actions on January 6

    by Kate Brannen and Ryan Goodman

    May 11th, 2021

  • #StopTheSteal: Timeline of Social Media and Extremist Activities Leading to 1/6 Insurrection

    by Atlantic Council's DFRLab

    Feb 10th, 2021

  • Incitement Timeline: Year of Trump’s Actions Leading to the Attack on the Capitol

    by Ryan Goodman, Mari Dugas and Nicholas Tonckens

    Jan 11th, 2021

  • Timeline of the Coronavirus Pandemic and U.S. Response

    by Ryan Goodman and Danielle Schulkin

    Nov 3rd, 2020

  • Timeline: The Trump Administration and the U.S. Postal Service

    by Chris Shenton

    Aug 24th, 2020

  • Timeline: Trump, Barr, and the Halkbank Case on Iran Sanctions-Busting

    by Ryan Goodman and Danielle Schulkin

    Jul 27th, 2020

  • Timeline on Jared Kushner, Qatar, 666 Fifth Avenue, and White House Policy

    by Ryan Goodman and Julia Brooks

    Mar 11th, 2020

  • Timeline: Trump, Giuliani, Biden, and Ukrainegate

    by Viola Gienger and Ryan Goodman

    Jan 31st, 2020

About the Author(s)

Marty Lederman

Professor at the Georgetown University Law Center. He was Deputy Assistant Attorney General at the Office of Legal Counsel from 2009-2010, and Attorney Advisor at the Office of Legal Counsel from 1994-2002. Member of the editorial board of Just Security. You can follow him on Twitter (@marty_lederman).

Send A Letter To The Editor

Read these related stories next:

Facebook Provided Warning to FBI Before January 6, GAO Report Reveals

by Justin Hendrix

May 5th, 2022

Friction, Framing & U.S. Cybersecurity-Related Actions Against Russia

by Kristen Eichensehr

Apr 7th, 2022

Amid New Trial, End of Chinese Espionage “Initiative” Brings Little Relief to US Academics Caught in Net of Fear

by Michael German and Alex Liang

Mar 22nd, 2022

Why Ending the Justice Department’s “China Initiative” is Vital to U.S. Security

by Michael German and Alex Liang

Jan 3rd, 2022

We Now Know What Information the FBI Can Obtain from Encrypted Messaging Apps

by Riana Pfefferkorn

Dec 14th, 2021

The Absence of “The Donald”

by Ryan Goodman and Justin Hendrix

Dec 6th, 2021

20 Years After the Patriot Act, America Must End Secret Law

by Senator Ron Wyden

Oct 26th, 2021

Rethinking Surveillance on the 20th Anniversary of the Patriot Act

by Sharon Bradford Franklin

Oct 26th, 2021

The Huawei DPA: A Prologue to the Global Arrest Game?

by Steven Arrigg Koh

Oct 8th, 2021

The Costs of 9/11’s Suspicionless Surveillance: Suppressing Communities of Color and Political Dissent

by Faiza Patel

Sep 8th, 2021

A Flaw in the Attorney General’s Policy Against Seizing Reporters’ Records

by George Croner

Aug 11th, 2021

Encryption Originalism

by Julian Sanchez

Jul 16th, 2021

Just Security logoA.M. Early EditionP.M. Today at Just Security

About Us

Just Security is based at the Reiss Center on Law and Security at New York University School of Law.

Contact Us Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Facebook
Accessibility
© 2022 Just Security