Today, the International Court of Justice found that the Republic of the Union of Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya ethnic group during its “clearance operations” in Northern Rakhine State in 2017. The Court applied its established interpretation of the Genocide Convention and its established standard of proof by fully convincing evidence. The Court found that Myanmar is legally obligated to offer restitution and compensation to surviving victims, with specific measures and amounts to be determined in future proceedings.
The Court’s 191-page judgment is largely devoted to a careful examination of the available evidence, including oral and written witness testimony as well as reports by the United Nations Independent International Fact-Finding Mission on Myanmar and the Independent Investigative Mechanism for Myanmar. This article merely summarizes the Court’s main conclusions. The Court also found Myanmar responsible for failing to prevent acts of genocide by private individuals, failing to punish acts of genocide, failing to adopt necessary legislation, and breaching the Court’s provisional measures orders relating to the preservation of evidence. This article will discuss only the Court’s finding that Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya.
First, the Court found that Myanmar’s government and security forces committed acts of: (1) killing members of the Rohingya group, (2) causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the Rohingya group, and (3) imposing measures intended to prevent births within the Rohingya group under article 2(a), (b), and (d), respectively, of the Genocide Convention. In particular, the Court found that Myanmar’s security forces killed at least 10,000 Rohingya, including through “the direct targeting of civilians, including women and very young children, and killings with knives and burning of people in houses. They also included killing by widespread indiscriminate shooting.”
The Court further found that Myanmar’s security forces caused “injuries resulting from shooting, knife wounds and burning. Widespread acts of rape, including gang and mass rape, and other forms of sexual violence, often accompanied by beatings or mutilation, also resulted in serious physical harm.” The Court also found that:
At least 1,834 acts of rape caused severe suffering for the victims, as well as suffering for their family members and persons who witnessed the acts. Approximately 326,000 Rohingya had their homes burned, leaving them with no place to return to, and many personally experienced the burning of their homes and villages. Finally, while not all of the approximately 700,000 Rohingya who were forced to flee experienced extreme hardship during the journey to Bangladesh, the evidence establishes that many of them did, and those who fled have not been allowed to return. (internal citations omitted)
Finally, the Court found that:
taken together, the restrictions on marriages and births on Rohingya in Maungdaw Township, where nearly 500,000 Rohingya resided, the denial of legal registration for Rohingya children and the commission of at least 1,834 acts of rape targeting the Rohingya population during the 2017 clearance operations, when viewed in the context of the Government’s messages regarding uncontrolled Rohingya population growth, establish an intent to impact the capacity of members of the Rohingya community to reproduce normally and thus an intent to prevent births within the group.
Accordingly, the Court found that the evidence conclusively establishes the commission of acts listed in article 2(a), (b), and (d) of the Genocide Convention
Second, the Court found that the “only reasonable inference” supported by the evidence is that Myanmar’s government and security forces acted with the specific intent to destroy the Rohingya group, in substantial part, as such. The Court inferred genocidal intent from several factors, including: the general context, including the perpetration of other culpable acts systematically directed against the group; selective targeting of the Rohingya; perpetration of acts that violate the foundations of the Rohingya group, including sexual violence and targeting children; and the systematic nature and scale of the relevant conduct. Notably, the Court found “that the fact that Myanmar did not take every opportunity it had to destroy members of the Rohingya group does not preclude an inference of genocidal intent.”
The Court considered that the 815,000 Rohingya of Northern Rakhine State constitute a substantial part of the Rohingya group based on numerical size alone. The Court clarified that while genocide concerns the intent to destroy a group physically or biologically, such destruction is not limited to the deaths of group members. Instead, the intent to partially destroy a group includes the intent to commit listed acts on such a scale as to “severely impact the existence of the protected group and its ability to function as a group.” Accordingly, determination of an intent to destroy a substantial part of the Rohingya group must take into account all group members targeted by listed acts, and not only those ultimately killed.
Crucially, the Court found that the evidence excludes any other reasonable inference, such as an intent to carry out counter-insurgency operations; an intent to displace the Rohingya without destroying them, even in substantial part; or an intent to collectively punish the Rohingya without destroying them even in substantial part. As the Court explained: “When some elements of the evidentiary record may allow additional intentions to be inferred, but the totality of the evidence can only be explained by the perpetrator’s genocidal intent, the only reasonable inference standard is met.”
For example, the Court found that “the execution of Rohingya men and boys in some locations, the widespread sexual violence, including gang and mass rape, the targeting of children and babies, the methodical burning of villages and attacks on fleeing civilians are not consistent with an intent to conduct counter-insurgency operations.” Similarly, the Court found that “a number of aspects of the clearance operations, including the brutal manner in which they were conducted, attacks by the security forces on the Rohingya as they fled to Bangladesh and the widespread attacks on young children, are not consistent with an intent to forcibly displace the population.” Finally, the Court found that “the scale and nature of Myanmar’s actions and the methods it employed went well beyond what would be required to punish the population and are instead characteristic of an intent to destroy a substantial part of the group. Features of such intent include the large numbers of persons killed, injured or displaced and the widespread brutal attacks on women and children.” In sum, genocidal intent was the only reasonable inference supported by the evidence.
The Court’s judgment was supported by nine judges, with six judges dissenting and all fifteen judges writing separately to explain their reasoning. A full discussion of these opinions and declarations will have to wait. For now, the Court has ruled that Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya. We can only hope that the Court’s judgment will offer some solace to survivors and some hope for a better future.






