A black-and-white photo of Abdul Rahman Pazhwak, then Afghanistan's Ambassador to the U.N., standing in profile at a podium with two microphones facing toward him as his left hand is placed over a small stack of papers.

Afghanistan’s 80 Years at the U.N.: Keeping the Torch in Times of Darkness

We have both held Afghanistan’s seat as permanent representative at the United Nations in Geneva, one (Dalil) as the first woman to lead our nation’s mission to the U.N., the other (Andisha) as the first diplomat of Afghanistan to serve as the vice-president of the Human Rights Council. In both cases, we represented the new generation of Afghanistan’s diplomatic service after the Taliban’s removal from power in late 2001.

This week, our country marks 80 years as a member of the U.N., having joined on Nov. 19, 1946 alongside Iceland and Sweden, among the first wave of nations admitted after the organization’s founding. Twelve years earlier, on Sept. 27, 1934, the League of Nations had welcomed Afghanistan here in Geneva, where we continue our work today. We defied the Taliban’s military takeover of our country, and we have rejected their policies and practices ever since, above all their assault on the human rights and dignity of our people. The Taliban refuse to honor Afghanistan’s international obligations, and the world, with the exception of Russia, refuses to recognize them. Our missions in Geneva, New York, and Vienna are therefore still led by diplomats who were accredited by the last constitutional government. We do not represent the Taliban and take no instructions from them; we serve the people of Afghanistan and adhere to the U.N. Charter and related conventions that our country signed over the past 80 years. 

We invoke Geneva deliberately. Long before the emerging multilateral system was fully formed, a small, landlocked, and fiercely independent country was eager to be an active member of the League of Nations, choosing the rule of law early. Afghanistan understood what every vulnerable State eventually learns: for a small and geographically exposed nation in an anarchic world, international law is an affordable armor of recognition and protection.

Eighty years later, that armor is being systematically dismantled. Where invading armies and warring empires once posed a threat, today it comes from a radical extremist movement occupying Kabul that claims the apparatus of the State while repudiating every obligation attached to it internationally. Yet, there is much the international community can still do to help defend the dignity and rights of the people of Afghanistan in the face of the Taliban’s repression.

The State that Was Built and Recognized in U.N. Halls

Through the Second World War, Afghanistan held to a strict neutrality while empires around it went to war. After the war, Afghanistan stood among founders of the Non-Aligned Movement (NAM) when the movement was conceived at the 1955 Bandung conference (Indonesia) and the 1961 Belgrade conference (former Yugoslavia). We defended self-determination and the sovereign equality of small States at the multilateral organizations. 

Afghanistan fought hardest on issues where its geography hurt it most. From 1958, it pressed the case for the rights of landlocked States. The jurist Abdul Hakim Tabibi carried that argument through the 1958 Geneva conference on the law of the sea and served as vice-chairman of the 1965 New York conference on transit trade. The argument was included in Part X of the 1982 U.N. Convention on the Law of the Sea. As a result, every landlocked country that invokes its right of access to the sea today draws on an argument Afghanistan pioneered. In his last years, Tabibi, once a civil servant of Afghanistan, lived in exile in Geneva, the city where he had won rights for countries like his own. We, too, live in Geneva now, not the first civil servants of Afghanistan to watch from afar as their home country is usurped by an extremist group. We are determined to be among the last.

On the other side of the Atlantic, at the U.N.’s New York headquarters, in 1966, Abdul Rahman Pazhwak presided over the General Assembly at one of the tensest moments of the Cold War. Afghanistan had been among the first States with majority Muslim populations to vote in favor of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights in 1948. In the decades that followed, it bound itself to the core of international human rights law: the two international covenants on human rights, the Convention against Racial Discrimination, the Convention against Torture, the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women, and the Rome Statute. In 2017, after a dedicated campaign, Afghanistan was elected to the Human Rights Council for the first time for the period from 2018 to 2020, and went on to serve as one of its vice-presidents.

Our record as a country is not spotless. Afghanistan lived through coups, invasion, civil war, and governments that failed their own people. But through monarchy and republics, the communists and Mujahidin, the State kept its signature on its treaties and its diplomats at the negotiating tables.

The Current Rulers are the Extreme Exception

In 80 years of membership, the only rulers of Kabul whom the U.N. has twice refused to seat are the Taliban: from 1996 to 2001 and again since August 2021. Kings, presidents, the communist governments of the 1980s, and the Mujahidin in the 1990s all held Afghanistan’s seat at the U.N. and represented the State in its international obligations. That makes the Taliban an exceptional departure from — and an interruption of — the continuity of Afghanistan’s statehood.

In the two decades before it seized Kabul in August 2021, the Taliban waged a brutal insurgency through suicide bombings, roadside improvised explosive devices, targeted assassinations, and attacks that caused mass civilian casualties, documented year after year by the U.N. Assistance Mission in Afghanistan. Schools, universities, hospitals, maternity wards and delivery rooms, public transport, shops, and restaurants were repeatedly targeted, without distinction. The Taliban destroyed national infrastructure, erased irreplaceable cultural heritage, and kidnapped foreign nationals as bargaining chips.

Now in power, they have turned that violence into law. More than 100 edicts have been issued against women and girls since 2021. Discrimination bars them from most employment and affects their healthcare, their access to civic space, and their freedom of movement and expression. Already for a fifth consecutive year, girls are barred from school beyond the sixth grade. Women of Afghanistan who work for the U.N. are barred from its premises in their own country. The U.N.’s own sanctions monitors describe a “permissive environment” for terrorist groups. The treaties Afghanistan signed have been dishonored without even the courtesy of withdrawal. The Taliban’s systematic discrimination against girls and women has been rightly described as gender apartheid. 

Five years on, a single country, Russia, has recognized the Taliban government. The phrase “de facto authorities,” too often used even in U.N. reports, already concedes too much. The Taliban hold power without legitimacy, which can only come from the people and from the obligations a State accepts; they have rejected both.

In the Room, Barely at the Table

For the past five years, Afghanistan’s missions in New York, Geneva, and Vienna have refused to hand the State’s credentials to the Taliban. Together with the women of Afghanistan, whose courage exposed the regime to the world, we have denied the Taliban what they want most: to be recognized as the State. But while we, the representatives behind the nameplate and the flag, attend, speak, and advocate, we cannot negotiate, because we couldn’t pay Afghanistan’s U.N. membership dues. Our voice has been reduced to testimony.

Meanwhile, the rules of this century are being written during every session without our votes: on artificial intelligence, pandemics, cybercrime, climate finance, intellectual property, trade, and the future of humanitarian law. Every one of them will bind Afghanistan’s future, and we are absent from the negotiating tables.

In 2021, right after the collapse of the internationally recognized government and the takeover by the Taliban, there was sympathy, much of it evidently rooted in guilt over the abandonment of so many Afghans who had supported a forward trajectory for the country, with international support, but who had been left behind when most of the international community fled. That sympathy is evaporating. The women of Afghanistan who were once invited to every panel are now invited to fewer. Governments that need one address in Kabul for deportations, transit, or counterterrorism find it convenient to have interlocutors there who are unaccountable to their people, and increasingly treat the Taliban as a non-State actor that happens to control a State’s territory, however illegitimately. The world may never recognize the Taliban formally, yet effectively it is conceding its control and beginning to ignore the fact that the real Afghanistan is missing from these exchanges.

Restoring Afghanistan Is a Joint Responsibility

Afghanistan cannot go on like this. A nation of more than 40 million people cannot remain a seat without a State, and a State without its people. Restoring it falls to all of us.

To the people of Afghanistan, at home and in exile, every woman and man, of every language, faith, and region: this seat is yours. It was never the property of a king, a ruler, a party, or a movement, and it will not become the property of the Taliban. We ask our diplomats, scholars, and civil society to unite around one cause, Afghanistan, the home of all its people: national sovereignty, liberty, justice, and peaceful coexistence with the world.

The two of us and our peers, who served in building a state and society over the past two decades are considered the bridge generation. Our task, beyond lamenting the mistakes that brought us to this point, is to carry Afghanistan forward, restoring its legitimate place among the nations.

Already, neighboring and regional States have noticed that an Afghanistan outside the law does not stay inside its borders. Stability bought from the Taliban is merely rented, and it comes at the cost of dignity and security.

Afghanistan’s credentials and seats at the U.N. and international organizations have to be tied to the rights of its people rather than to whoever holds a gun to their heads. Until there is a political settlement, these organizations must consistently invite the credentialed representatives, the women, and civil society of Afghanistan into the rooms where the U.N.’s future, and the world’s new rules, are decided.

For five years, our missions in New York, Geneva, and Vienna have carried a torch in the name of the State and people of Afghanistan. It was passed to us by 80 years of patriotic service and honorable diplomacy by those who served before, from Pazhwak to Tabibi, and those of us still in these positions will keep it lit until the people of Afghanistan can take it back. In 1946, Afghanistan joined the new world order and eagerly embraced the obligations of international law. Eighty years later, its people ask for the same thing. The Taliban are an aberration. The world body should neither mistake them for the representatives of Afghanistan nor normalize a regime of gender apartheid.

Filed Under

, , , , , , , , , , , , ,
Send A Letter To The Editor

DON'T MISS A THING. Stay up to date with Just Security curated newsletters: