Guantanamo Dispatches: USS Cole Bombing Trial Recesses With First 8 Jury Members Chosen

Jury selection in the USS Cole bombing case at Guantanamo Bay recessed until next month with the addition of an eighth member who recently served on a base in the Middle East that came under fire in the U.S. war against Iran. 

Army Col. Matthew Fitzgerald, the judge, accepted the Air Force captain over the objections of a defense lawyer who argued that the officer should be disqualified because aspects of the juror’s recent wartime experience were similar to some of the facts in the Cole case.

The captain was sent to Saudi Arabia last year on a routine deployment, a peacetime mission as he saw it, before the U.S.-Iran war began. Then, this year, his base came under attack. Airmen under his command were injured by shrapnel and concussion injuries from either drone or missile fire.

In the Cole attack, the warship’s commander also believed he was on a peacetime mission, a routine refueling stop in the port of Aden, Yemen, when al-Qaeda struck on Oct. 12, 2000, killing 17 American sailors. 

Casey Secor, a defense lawyer, told the judge that the jurors at the Cole trial will be shown disturbing images of U.S. sailors who were killed and wounded in the suicide bombing 25 years ago, and the Air Force captain’s reactions could be colored by the casualties experienced by his servicemembers.

At Guantánamo, a Saudi prisoner, Abd al-Rahim al-Nashiri, is accused of orchestrating the attack on the Cole by two al-Qaeda operatives who came alongside the ship in an explosives-laden skiff and ignited their load.

His is the first death-penalty case by military commission at Guantanamo Bay. The court is choosing a total of 20 U.S. officers. Twelve will serve as jurors and six as alternates. The prosecution and defense teams can each excuse one of the 20 without cause.

The Air Force officer who was added to the panel was 2 years old when the Cole was bombed. He underwent some of the most intensive questioning by defense lawyers since jury selection began on Nov. 4. He said he did not believe the death penalty was necessarily required in a case like the one against al-Nashiri.

But he also could not imagine sentencing someone convicted of all of the charges in the case to no prison sentence, the most lenient sentence available to the military jurors, if al-Nashiri is convicted at the trial, which starts in earnest next year. 

“If they were guilty of all these charges,” he said, “getting no punishment would do a disservice to the legal system.”

The Air Force officer juror said he believed al-Nashiri was probably guilty of something because he had been held at Guantanamo Bay for 20 years. He said he hoped the military had done “its due diligence” in keeping him so long without “a speedy trial.”

It was not explained to the officer that al-Nashiri is held as an enemy combatant, and therefore the U.S. government considers him eligible for detention for the duration of the conflict with al-Qaeda, even if he is never convicted of any crime. Prospective jurors also have not been told about al-Nashiri’s first four years of detention by the CIA, during which he was tortured repeatedly.

Secor, the capital defense lawyer, also argued for disqualification of the Air Force captain because of his belief that the prisoner must be guilty of something. 

“The test here is, will the member yield to the evidence presented and your honor’s instructions,” said Army Lt. Col. Michael Ross, a prosecutor in the case. He called it “ridiculous” to expect a prospective juror to seriously consider “a sentence of no punishment for mass murder” without context and evidence in mitigation.

Judge Fitzgerald said the officer’s answers did not meet the definition of actual or implied bias toward any course of action, and declared him “thoughtful, contemplative, and forthcoming in his answers.”

With that, jury selection thus far has chosen three Air Force officers, three Army officers and one each from the Navy and Marine Corps. The most senior member is an Air Force colonel who plans to retire next year. The youngest is a Navy lieutenant missile officer who serves on a submarine.

The pool of potential jurors is made up of about 200 U.S. military officers stationed in both domestic and overseas bases. The next 18 candidates arrive after Thanksgiving with group questioning of those officers to start on Dec. 2. 

Filed Under

, , , , , ,
Send A Letter To The Editor

DON'T MISS A THING. Stay up to date with Just Security curated newsletters: