On Nov. 9, the President nominated T. Elliot Gaiser, the lawyer who heads the Department of Justice’s Office of Legal Counsel, to be a federal district judge in Texas.
This news came as a shock to many lawyers, especially those of us who watch with grave concern as the administration continues its killing spree in the Caribbean Sea and Eastern Pacific Ocean. To date, those strikes have taken 243 lives. In stark contrast, the U.S. Coast Guard’s overwhelmingly nonviolent drug interdiction patrols are successfully halting or reducing drug running in the same waters. Three former senior Coast Guard officials have summed up the campaign as “legally unsound, strategically counterproductive, and morally corrosive.”
The administration’s affront to legal constraints on the use of military force intensified when it proceeded to attack Iran without congressional approval in violation of the Constitution, the War Powers Act, and international law (see Bridgeman and Hathaway).
Mr. Gaiser is the legal architect of robbing the Congress of its constitutional place
At the center of these outrageously illegal uses of the U.S. military is the Office of Legal Counsel. As its head – a position for which he was not qualified but for which the Senate confirmed him by a narrow party line vote of 53-45 – Mr. Gaiser has been the government’s chief source of legal advice justifying both. Yet, as perhaps a measure of the administration’s confidence in that legal advice, neither of Mr. Gaiser’s written opinions has been made public.
Notably, Mr. Gaiser’s memo on the Venezuela operations resulting in Maduro’s capture and rendition, which was released in redacted form, is often legally incoherent and replaces analysis with an almost shocking deference to the president. The overwhelming weight of expert analysis is that this operation, like the ongoing Iran War and boat strikes, was unlawful under domestic and international law. And Mr. Gaiser’s “misstatement of the law” in the other respects has “sweeping implications” for the protection of civilians in armed conflict.
It is notable that these uses of military force run afoul of Article I of the Constitution – giving Congress the power to declare war, alongside a host of other adjacent powers – and of the 1973 War Powers Resolution (WPR) that was intended to ensure Congress has tools to constrain the president in unilateral uses of force.
Senators of both parties have every reason to be especially concerned, as Mr. Gaiser is the legal architect of robbing the Congress of its constitutional place and making an end-run around the War Powers Resolution. Senators – including Republicans – who voted for the resolutions to constrain the Iran War in whole or in part on the basis that it is being waged without congressional authorization should be particularly opposed to this nomination.
A few Members of Congress appear to have read or have had the opportunity to read the opinions Mr. Gaiser signed. We hope the senators who have read them will consider them in their confirmation deliberations. They are, by all accounts, disqualifying. For the rest of us, “hope” is not a strategy. Just as we have demanded that these opinions be released to the public so that our military personnel will see the advice on which their orders are premised, we now demand their publication as part of the democratic process of appointing a life tenured judge.
President Trump’s judicial nominations have been a mixed bag. Some have been within the realm of reason, others not so much. Many lawyers across the country were appalled when the Senate confirmed Emil J. Bove III for a lifetime seat on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit. The appointment of judges is a political process. Democrats and Republicans have long engaged in horse trading judicial appointments; sometimes, the politics leads to disappointing results. Rather than dismissing Mr. Gaiser’s nomination as “politics as usual,” the midterm elections should tell Congress that the American people insist on better.
Any reasonable Senator ought to seriously question whether someone like Mr. Gaiser has the character and professional temperament necessary to serve as a judge. It is one thing to advocate for clients as an attorney. It is another to distort the law for political purposes and then refuse to release the opinions that have resulted in the loss of hundreds of lives — some of them American troops.
Whether or not the Senate will give its “advice and consent” remains to be seen. Perhaps Mr. Gaiser will impress Senators when he has the opportunity to meet with them or in the course of his confirmation hearing. But that hearing must not be a charade. Senators and the American public must be afforded an opportunity to study the Iran war and boat strikes legal opinions for which he is responsible, as well as any other OLC legal opinion impacting major initiatives of the Trump administration. Both the nominee and qualified witnesses should testify in public and be subjected to meaningful questioning. Ultimately, Mr. Gaiser’s fitness to serve as a federal judge should be based on his willingness to place the law above his allegiance to any president, not vice versa.





