Guantanamo Dispatches: First Marine Added, Space Force Officer Excused from USS Cole Jury

The military judge added a lieutenant colonel in the Marine Corps as a provisional member of the capital jury in the USS Cole bombing case Monday, the third female officer on the panel for the first death penalty trial by military commission at Guantanamo Bay.

The colonel is a supply officer who was in college at the time of the 9/11 attacks and was commissioned about eight years later. She said she served in a massive 1,600-acre base in southern Afghanistan in 2012 but had no encounters with the enemy or local citizens. 

She also declared herself open to the range of potential sentencing options — from no time to the death penalty — if the military jury were to convict the defendant Abd al-Rahim al-Nashiri, a Saudi, of war crimes related to the bombing of the Cole on Oct. 12, 2000. 

Seventeen sailors were killed and dozens of others were wounded in the attack, which crippled the Navy destroyer while it was on a refueling stop in Aden Harbor in Yemen. 

Al-Nashiri has been a prisoner of the United States since soon after he was arrested in Dubai in 2002. He was held for the first four years by the CIA in secret overseas prisons, where he was tortured. He was first brought before a judge for arraignment in 2011.

“I’m very neutral on the death penalty. It’s very situation dependent,” the colonel told Allison Miller, al-Nashiri’s capital defense lawyer. She also said she could not imagine giving someone convicted of a capital crime no punishment aside from the conviction “if the person was guilty and they have not served time for the crimes committed. I don’t think the appropriate punishment would be to just let that person go, just with a rap sheet.”

Col. Matthew Fitzgerald, the judge, has yet to decide whether al-Nashiri’s lawyers will be able to tell the panel members that, guilty or innocent, he may be held indefinitely, potentially forever, as an al-Qaeda detainee in the war against terrorism.

With Monday’s addition, the panel now has seven members – three Army officers, two Air Force officers and one each from the Navy and Marine Corps. Thirteen more are needed for the panel of 12 jurors and six alternates. Once 20 are chosen, the defense and prosecution teams can each excuse a member for no reason.

Earlier in the day, defense and prosecution lawyers agreed to excuse a Space Force lieutenant colonel, who described himself as a member of the Intelligence Community who had worked well with the CIA throughout his career. The officer, one of the founding members of the force that was established in 2019, also said he was needed at his squadron because there was no second in command who could replace him.

That excusal left just two more officers to be questioned this week before Thanksgiving, with jury selection to resume Dec. 1 at the earliest with a new batch of 18 pool members.

Filed Under

, , , , , , ,
Send A Letter To The Editor

DON'T MISS A THING. Stay up to date with Just Security curated newsletters: