Though it is with great disappointment that the sanctions imposed by the United States preclude me from being with you in New York today, I am very grateful to the American Branch of the International Law Association for having given me the opportunity to be heard nonetheless. Please know I am also with you in spirit!
I am particularly pleased to be speaking just after my former boss and dear friend Silvia Fernandez de Gurmendi has received this well-deserved honor from ABILA. Her career and her continuing efforts are inspirational to us all.
It is a bit daunting to address you, after what must have been interesting but sober discussions throughout the weekend. Your program highlights the challenges. In different fields – climate, trade, arms control, health; so many precepts and systems we took as fundamental and given are under threat, across these legal disciplines. But I consider it my role today, while recognizing the seriousness of the challenges that we face, to direct our focus on to the way forward. We know that developing and maintaining international law, in particular international criminal law, was always going to be extraordinarily challenging. Currently, we are facing very turbulent times in that regard, as in an airplane, one of those moments when flight attendants are asked to take their seats. And we must act in the same manner to address this turbulence, as in an aircraft. We need to keep calm, steady the course, take any necessary corrective measures, and ride out the bumps, knowing, in due course, we will arrive if not to clear skies, at least calmer ones. I am confident that is how international law will emerge from this difficult period.
In that regard I love the conference theme – (R)evolution in the International Legal Order – which gives me options – revolution or evolution in international law? I strictly choose the latter. What we are seeing is an evolution – one that will unquestionably bring some changes and some losses but will not result in the overturn or discarding of the entire regime of international law – the rules-based order which we have fought so hard to attain.
In that spirit, while I will focus my comments today on international criminal law and the International Criminal Court, I know that all of us in our various fields face the same the same sense of horror, frustration and fear – that what we have long strived for is being summarily upended. I hope I convey a message today that resonates across all these fields and generates, albeit in different ways, motivation to find ways forward for international law, in all its manifestations.
In turning to my specific topic, I will not recount in any detail what is well known to this audience – the targeted strikes which have been aimed at the Court and the system which surrounds it. Individual judges and prosecutors subject to intimidation tactics, arrest warrants, in absentia convictions and debilitating sanctions for doing their jobs in accordance with their oaths of office. Civil society organizations and UN officials, providing critical support to the core work of the institution, similarly targeted. In a further escalation, on 9th October, the International Criminal Court – the institution – was designated by the United States and added to a list designed for those implicated in terrorism, organized crime and human rights abuses. Even with the licenses which are granted for the moment, the reality is the Court is designated and will face disruptions. Moreover, the purpose is clear – to attack the Court through comprehensive economic sanctions aimed at crippling its operations.
As to the overall aim of the administration – it is no longer a matter of speculation. The Secretary of State has explained it in plain terms– “…we will tear down the Court brick by brick.” There can be no doubt. This is not an isolated attack on an institution but rather a full assault on international justice and the rule of law. The vision behind it is a world order where victims of atrocities are ignored and it is a strike in favor of ending accountability and advancing impunity for those who commit the gravest crimes known to humankind.
But I will not dwell on that message. I will turn to the latter part of my discourse – the way forward. To the question posed by some in these challenging moments – are we witnessing the demise of international criminal justice and the ICC? – I respond with a resounding no.
History instructs us that implementing a system for international criminal justice was always going to be incredibly hard to achieve. Look back to the period post-WWII and all the steps forward that were possible in the wake of that horrific conflict – the establishment of the United Nations, the International Court of Justice, the International Law Commission and adoption of the Universal Declaration on Human Rights. But what could not be agreed on was the creation of a permanent international criminal court. This despite the precedents of the Nuremberg and Tokyo tribunals. Sadly, for decades after, we slipped backwards – with atrocity crimes being perpetrated in various countries around the globe, with victims having no prospect for justice. But history at the same time shows us possibility. While it took many years and much determination, when that perfect storm of conditions generated the moment – we were ready. On Jul. 17, 1998, the Rome Statute was adopted and four years later it took force – an operational permanent international criminal court had finally been achieved.
We face today a changed world and a set of conditions which would make this accomplishment impossible. However, drawing from this experience, and having seen ICL grow up from infancy, I remain confident that the current circumstances do not represent an irreparable collapse but rather a setback, just as we have experienced before. It is a setback which can be countered by ensuring that this current crisis motivates us to step up our efforts – renew and increase them – to not only sustain what we have achieved, but to advance further. Alas, there is no roadmap to success, but here are some fundamental steps.
Firstly, we need clear communication about the ICC. Interestingly, in preparing this presentation I had considered that this part would be aspirational – what we must seek to achieve. I called for voices and actions in support of international criminal justice and the ICC to demonstrate how essential it is, not just as a legal concept but as a grassroots belief. Thankfully, in the intervening time we have begun to see this develop. From different corners of the globe – civil society in various formations, along with political figures, judicial, legal, academic and parliamentary associations, national and international, raising their unique voices. From Prime Minister Jetten’s speech to the United Nations with the much- quoted declaration – “Hands off the ICC” to the Joint Statement of the Coalition for the ICC supported by 120 civil society organizations, in over 60 countries to 8 Bar associations from different regions including the American Bar Association and International Bar Association, issuing a statement against sanctions. In terms of actions, we have also seen extraordinary moments. The awarding of the Nobel Peace prize to Navi Pillay could not have sent a stronger message as she stands for all of these principles – international justice, rule of law and human rights. Recently, the European Parliament awarded the Sakharov prize for freedom of thought to the ICC and its officials. All of these statements and actions serve to introduce or remind of the imperative of international criminal justice and the work of the ICC and the Rome Statue system writ large. I urge each and every one of you to think about what contribution you can make to this campaign of support.
Similarly, the ICC is perhaps the most misunderstood institution in the world. We have to use the opportunity that the recent attention presents to make clear what it is and what it is not. Most importantly, we have to counter the totally false narratives being presented, especially within the United States, about this Court. That is something we must do together: we at the Court, but perhaps even more importantly, you. In various roles – academia, civil society, as lawyers, judges, teachers – we need to reach as broad an audience as possible and communicate our message as a matter of general public interest.
To this audience, I need not explain in detail the false narratives or the responses to them. But I do need to hit a couple of highlights arising from the recent statements of Secretary of State Rubio.
First, the ICC does not existentially threaten the sovereignty of the United States or any other state. To the contrary, the whole point of the Rome Statute is to motivate, cajole, encourage states to exercise their sovereign right and investigate and prosecute these atrocity crimes. Where any State genuinely does so, the ICC has no jurisdiction. This is a principle not only set out in the statute but one which has been implemented in practice through ICC jurisprudence, with challenges of states having been accepted. The ICC acts where the choice is between pursuing justice or allowing and encouraging impunity. One day, I would like to ask those so focused on dismantling this court – what option/alternative do you give to the thousands of victims of the crimes that we are currently investigating and prosecuting because no one else will?
Secondly, the ICC does not claim illegitimate jurisdiction over non-state parties or target officials of non-states parties for acts committed within their own state. The ICC acts solely within the confines of the Rome Statute and has jurisdiction with respect to the acts of nationals of non-states parties only when there is a link to a state party, namely where a crime is alleged to have been committed by a non-state party national, on the territory of a State Party. That form of jurisdiction is a basic principle of international law that a State has the exclusive right to adopt and apply law on its territory. If that State is a party to the Rome Statute, it has accepted that the jurisdiction of the ICC will apply on the territory, to everyone, equally. Nationality does not shield from the application of the law of the land, as determined by the territorial State.
We need to replace these accounts of the Court with the truth. The work of the Court is not political and it targets no one, except those which evidence indicates have perpetrated the worst crimes know to humankind. Moreover, at the center of the work of the Court are the victims. Bringing justice through fair trials and repairing harm through awards of reparations is the mission of the ICC and the Rome Statute system.
The challenge at this important juncture is to ensure that these truths are disseminated – especially to the younger generation who must carry this project forward. To succeed we must work together to do so.
Secondly, an essential response to all of these coercive measures is to stand defiant and focus entirely on doing our jobs and doing them as effectively and efficiently as we can.
I am not one who ever shies away from acknowledging that the Court has had many challenges, in terms of its ways of working and efficiencies in investigation and adjudication. We must accept that and be open to constructive criticism and to making changes and improvements. It is how we become more effective at fulfilling our mandate and generating support for our work.
On that point, I am happy to report that during my over 10 years at the court, I have seen that happen- remarkable progress – across the court in improving our processes and effectively implementing the hybrid legal system of the Rome Statute. I am confident that will continue. As well, despite the challenges of operating in diverse situations around the globe, the Court has carried out multiple investigations and mounted a number of prosecutions, for a range of crimes, with convictions and acquittals like any national court. Today, the Court continues to be busy with 13 situations, in different parts of the world, and activity in all three divisions, including two trials about to commence.
In sum, to continue to do our work, to strive to be better at it, to focus on fair trials and justice for victims is the best response we can give to these outrageous coercive measures. It will demonstrate that the measures are futile – we will continue our work, we will not be intimidated. Further, the Court will be seen for what it is and what it does, in stark contrast to the fiction those who attack it seek to disseminate.
Equally important is that all those who render such critical support to this court through their work – and I recognize there are many in the room today – continue to do so as academics, lawyers, civil society, in advisory and other roles. In this regard, I fully acknowledge the special challenges Americans may face. On that point, I wish to convey deep appreciation on behalf of all of us at the Court for the legal challenges being advanced by individuals and organizations seeking redress against these sanctions, in order to continue efforts to support international criminal justice and the work of the Court. In parallel, there is teaching and academic writings – including critical pieces – and efforts to advance and improve national capacity – a central component of the Rome statute system – such as the upcoming negotiations on the Crimes against Humanity Convention and the efforts on implementation of the Hague/Ljubljana treaty. These combined actions are perhaps the strongest rebuke possible to the attacks being rendered.
Finally, this is a moment when States Parties must step to the forefront – history will judge what they do. The Court, in partnership with our host state, has worked hard to build resilience to the sanctions and there are many success stories in that regard. But with the recent escalation, when a non-state party mounts such a direct attack on the Court as an institution and the Rome Statute system as a whole, it is the States who must forcefully speak and act to defend it. This is not the prosecutors’ court, it is not the judges’ court. It is the States’ court and they must safeguard it.
To this end, political support is indispensable. We need individual and collective statements, as far as possible, but also diplomacy, quiet and loud, in support of the Court. But at this juncture we also require more concrete measures to be taken, to counter the implementation of sanctions, particularly those aimed at preventing over-compliance by businesses not compelled to do so. In Europe and elsewhere there needs to be an assertion of sovereignty through the adoption of blocking statutes. Despite limitations, they will provide an important level of protection on a practical level and send a clear political message. At the same time, in parallel, States need to dialogue with businesses, especially financial institutions, to counter the automatic compliance system, that I know very well from my “ironic” experience with both sides of sanctions. They need to communicate, by every means possible, that these sanctions are not binding, that the State opposes them, that the International Criminal Court is an essential institution which has privileges and immunities. Finally, it is important to remind the private sector that taking the decision to over-comply and voluntarily implement these sanctions makes you complicit in threatening judges and in attacking the International Criminal Court.
In other words, the consequences of the now-imposed institutional sanctions are serious and the response must be equally grave and clear. The moment has come to respond in a united and forceful way.
I will stop there and conclude with what gives me the most hope in these very difficult times. It is the believe I hold that the ICC and Rome Statute system will withstand this onslaught because justice is an imperative. It is an imperative that victims will not allow to be diminished. We have gone from justice being impossible to possible to now an expectation. It is one we still cannot begin to fulfil on an individual level, but it will not be denied as a principle. I hold to that when I have moments of despair and hope you will as well.
Thank you.








