Seeking Consensus on AUMFs

by , and

November 15, 2014

[Cross-posted at Lawfare]

The three of us have coauthored an Op-Ed in Sunday’s Washington Post on the topic of congressional authorization for the use of force against ISIL and the 2001 AUMF.  We outline the broad underlying agreement we personally share and that we believe is shared by two proposals published earlier this week at Lawfare and Just Security. 

Featured Articles

Why it’s a mistake to be a-waitin’ “the” Mueller Report (and why you should instead focus on two other reports)

by

Body Counts Are Terrible Way for the Public to Assess US Counter-Terrorism Operations

by

Recap of Recent Pieces on Just Security (March 11-15)

by

New Zealand Attacks: A Wake-Up Call to Counter Far-Right Extremist Violence

by and

Arbitrary Detention of Asylum Seekers Perpetuates the Torture of Family Separation

by , and

National Security at the United Nations This Week

by

Trump Investigations and the RICO vs Conspiracy Puzzle

by

What Comes Next: After Supreme Court Reduced Obstacles to Suing International Organizations

by

Time to Rehabilitate the Legislative Veto: How Congress Should Rein in Presidents’ “National Emergency” Powers

by and

After Hanoi, What Now?

by and

Reflecting on the Civilian Casualty Executive Order: What Was Lost and What Can Now Be Gained

by

The US-Philippines Defense Treaty and the Pompeo Doctrine on South China Sea

by

Citizenship-Stripping and ISIS Members: The Recent UK Experience

by

I Helped Write the Exec Order on Public Reporting of Lethal Operations. Here’s What Trump Has Undone.

by

Homeland Security’s Intelligence Overreach: Two Cases Illustrate Risks to Civil Society

by

The Ripening: The House Judiciary Committee Investigation Will Bear Fruit

by

Report of the Independent UN Commission of Inquiry on Gaza Strip – An Initial Evaluation of a Problematic Report

by

Can Trump Organization Executives be Prosecuted for Money Laundering?

by

BREAKING: United States Supports Germany’s International Arrest Warrant for Accused Syrian War Criminal

by

EU ‘Terrorist Content’ Proposal Sets Dire Example for Free Speech Online

by

Trump Told Cohen to Lie to Congress About “Collusion” in General—Not just the Moscow Tower deal

by

Counterterrorism and Homeland Security Are Not the Same Thing

by

The Missing Khashoggi Report: A President Can’t Choose to “Decline” His Constitutional Role to Accommodate Congressional Oversight

by , and

The Seven Step Program for Fighting Disinformation

by and

Trump’s Invoking Obama Signing Statement as Reason Not to Report to Congress on Khashoggi Murder: A Roundup of Expert Views

by

Mueller’s Findings: Why DOJ Non-Disclosure Policy and Grand Jury Secrecy May Not Apply

by and

What’s the Mission in Syria? The Answer May be Illegal and Without U.S. Allies’ Support

by

Power Struggle Over the Wall: Presidential Emergency Powers vs. Congressional Power of the Purse

by

About that Trial Balloon on Using the 9/11 AUMF to Authorize U.S. Strikes on Iran

by and

Unpacking (Some of) the Legal Issues Surrounding Hoda Muthana

by

What You Need to Know about the “National Emergency Declaration”

by

Who is Richard Burr, Really? Why the public can’t trust his voice in the Russia probe

by

The Pentagon’s Latest Report on Civilian Casualties Policy

by and

Gendered Security and the Right to Life: Analysis of UN Human Rights Committee’s General Comment

by

Wolf in Sheep’s Clothing: Does the McConnell amendment provide a justification for military operations against Iran?

by and

Human Rights, Deprivation of Life and National Security: Q&A with Christof Heyns and Yuval Shany on General Comment 36

by , and

Proportionality and Doubt

by

Roger Stone Indictment Implicates Trump Campaign in Election Law Violations

by

Saudi Coalition “Admission” of Error in Bombing Cholera Treatment Center Implicates the United States

by

A Dangerous Bet on Recognition in Venezuela

by

Pentagon’s Climate Change Report Lacks Analysis the Law Requires

by

New House Rules Promote Aggressive Congressional Oversight

by

The Status of Guantanamo 17 Years In

by and

Trump Campaign in Legal Jeopardy Over Manafort’s Sharing Data with Russian Agent

by

Weapons of Mass Consumerism: Why China Wants Your Personal Information

by and

Executive Agreements: International Lawmaking Without Accountability?

by , and

Annotation of the Pentagon Report to Congress on Detainee Abuse by U.S. Partners in Yemen

by

A Caution to Pentagon Officials Asked to Obligate “National Emergency” Funds

by

Terrorists and the Southern Border: Myth and Reality

by

Trump’s Plan to Have the Military Build a Wall is Illegal

by

Ruminations on RICO and Asset Forfeiture in the Trump Business Empire

by

Coming to Terms with the Impeachment Process: The Case for Starting a Formal Inquiry

by

Please Support Just Security with a Tax-Deductible Donation

by

Trump’s Bookkeeper: How Prosecutors Could Easily Prove Tax Crimes for Hush Money Reimbursements

by

Did Trump Organization Executives Cook the Books?–Tax Crimes Explained under Federal and State Law

by

Why It Doesn’t Matter Whether It’d Be Constitutional to Indict Trump

by

10 Ways the U.S. Can Curb Interpol Abuses

by

Mueller’s Roadmap: Major Takeaways from Cohen and Manafort Filings

by and

Perjury Chart: Trump Associates’ Lies, False, or Misleading Statements on Russia to Federal Authorities

by

Yes, Collusion: The Legal Significance of the New Mueller Revelations

by and

No Clean Hands: Reaction and Counter-Reaction in the Iranian-Saudi Proxy War in Yemen

by

Birthright Citizenship for Children of Unlawful U.S. Immigrants Remains an Open Question

by and

Prosecuting Wikileaks, Protecting Press Freedoms: Drawing the Line at Knowing Collaboration with a Foreign Intelligence Agency

by

Need for Change to Protect Children in Armed Conflict

by and

Why the First Amendment Does Not Protect Trump Campaign Collusion with Wikileaks and Russia

by and

Accountability Fatigue: A Human Rights Law Problem for Armed Forces?

by

Annotation of Sec. Pompeo’s Certification of Yemen War: Civilian Casualties and Saudi-Led Coalition

by

An Explainer: Senate’s Letter on Khashoggi and the Global Magnitsky Act

by

What Facts Would Deny the Trump Campaign First Amendment Protections in Colluding with Russia

by

Grading the Pompeo Certification on Yemen War and Civilian Protection: Time for Serious Reconsideration

by

The Technicolor Zone of Cyberspace, Part 2

by and

UPDATE: Mapping States’ Reactions to the Syria Strikes of April 2018

by , , and

View all »
About the Author(s)

Jack Goldsmith

Henry L. Shattuck Professor at Harvard Law School, Senior Fellow at the Hoover Institution, Former Assistant Attorney General of the Office of Legal Counsel (2003-2004), Former Special Counsel to the Department of Defense (2002-2003). You can follow him on Twitter (@jacklgoldsmith).

Ryan Goodman

Co-Editor-in-Chief of Just Security, Anne and Joel Ehrenkranz Professor of Law at New York University School of Law, former Special Counsel to the General Counsel of the Department of Defense (2015-2016). You can follow him on Twitter @rgoodlaw.

Steve Vladeck

Co-Editor-in-Chief of Just Security and Professor of Law at the University of Texas School of Law. Follow him on Twitter (@steve_vladeck).